'The New Governor' No.5 (mid/late 1930s)

Discussion in 'John Shaw & Sons (JS&S)' started by igh371, Apr 9, 2024.

  1. igh371

    igh371 SotM Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Joined:
    Jun 23, 2013
    Messages:
    2,834
    Location:
    Durham
    DSC03088.JPG
    Another example of this sad failure of British stove innovation. Infamous for attempting to be too clever-by-half in the innovation stakes, whilst at the same time failing dismally when it came to basic production quality control. These issues are already well covered in detail in two previous posts, here and here. So it will come as no surprise to be told that this example is plagued by the usual tank stress cracks.
    On the other hand, however, there is some merit to posting this further example. First, it provides an answer to a question raised back in 2011 as to what burner was originally fitted. The answer is that Shaws had their own burner made specifically for this stove, and this is the first example to have come to light:
    DSC03071.JPG

    DSC03084.JPG DSC03086.JPG
    So now we know.

    Secondly the clever lockable pump mechanism is almost like new, enabling very clear illustrations to be made available:
    DSC03069.JPG

    DSC03072.JPG DSC03073.JPG DSC03075.JPG DSC03077.JPG

    The tank looks superficially decent:
    DSC03087.JPG DSC03074.JPG DSC03080.JPG DSC03081.JPG DSC03082.JPG

    The stress cracks, however, are certainly there, in this case at least 6 spread around the bottom edge flange:
    DSC03094.JPG DSC03093.JPG


    It is, nevertheless, just sufficiently intact for a demonstration burn:
    DSC03092.JPG
     
    Last edited: Apr 9, 2024
  2. Nicola Francesco Elia

    Nicola Francesco Elia Italy SotM Winner SotY Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Joined:
    Nov 13, 2016
    Messages:
    3,155
    Location:
    Italy
    @igh371 a good find and a pity that these stoves suffer of stress cracks.

    It’s funny to think about all the efforts made to seal the pump NRV with that clever locking system (like primus 76/77 etc. and some lamps as well) and have multiple leaks for poor quality control on the brass forming…

    The synthesis of life.

    Nicola
     
  3. Blackdog

    Blackdog United Kingdom SotM Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Joined:
    Jan 7, 2009
    Messages:
    3,421
    Location:
    Dreaming of snow
    Yes a real shame considering the attention to detail in all other areas- reinforced riser to tank joint, external NRV for ease of maintenance, lighting device, broad feet... it must have cost a fortune to develop and tool up to produce.

    The locking pump seems unnecessary extra expense, although at the time any such innovation was surely desirable as a marketing feature over the long established Swedish brands. I suppose however it would get a meal finished or allow cooking for a few days until time or parts could be found to service the NRV. But in combination with an easy access external NRV it seems even less useful...

    Anyway, very nice, very interesting, a sad case of 'if only'.