Thread sizes Optimus and Svea

Diskussion i 'Stove Forum' startad av mirumir, 26 december 2022.

  1. JP2

    JP2 Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    26 juni 2018
    Inlägg:
    1.528
    Från:
    Canada
    Thanks for the link Ken.
    Nice stove, I will do some read about that stove now.
     
  2. ROBBO55

    ROBBO55 Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    27 oktober 2014
    Inlägg:
    2.701
    Från:
    Somersby, New South Wales, Australia
    @mirumir

    I measured an Optimus 8R and tried to match them to a usable standard metric thread. I Hope this helps

    Bell
    Thread measured 11.3mm diameter
    26 TPI Calculates to 0.98 pitch
    A M11 x 1.0 is a sloppy fit but a M12 x 1.0 was too large.

    Optimus 8R bell thread.jpg

    Nipple
    Thread measured 7.6mm diameter
    32 TPI Calculates to 0.79 pitch (could be a slight error due to short thread)
    A M8 x 0.75 worked on this one so should be OK, especially if you use a split die

    Optimus 8R nipple thread.jpg

    Filler Cap
    Thread measured 19mm diameter
    18 TPI Calculates to 1.41 pitch
    A M19 x 1.5 should be OK (didn’t have one to try)

    Good luck
     
    Last edited: 29 december 2022
  3. mirumir Ukraine

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    11 december 2022
    Inlägg:
    26
    Från:
    Ukraine
    Hello. I am very grateful to you . Another question is the thread sizes, are they the same for 8R, 99, 123? Respectfully
     
  4. OMC

    OMC United States Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    13 september 2013
    Inlägg:
    5.766
    Från:
    ILLINOIS, USA
    I too am grateful to ROBBO55, that was an excellent answer :thumbup::thumbup:.
    --------------

    mirumir, given the prev. comments i am sure you meant to say 123R.
    Yes, the 8R, 99 & 123R tulip & nipple threads are the same between the 3.

    You already know but for others, re the stout Russian PT1 (8R look alike), the tulip, nipple & filler cap threads all differ from 8r.
     
  5. mirumir Ukraine

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    11 december 2022
    Inlägg:
    26
    Från:
    Ukraine
    Fine ! Thank you so much . Soon I will be able to offer silent burners for 8R, 98, 123R. And separately on Fri 1. Respectfully
     
  6. mirumir Ukraine

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    11 december 2022
    Inlägg:
    26
    Från:
    Ukraine
    Hello . Today, I bought a tap 11/1, cut the thread ... Alas, it doesn’t fit, it doesn’t screw on ... Probably, you need to look for an inch tap.
     
  7. OMC

    OMC United States Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    13 september 2013
    Inlägg:
    5.766
    Från:
    ILLINOIS, USA
    @mirumir we're into day 5 on this. i was not clear on your objective but your question was straight-forward. being war-torn Ukraine i felt some urgency with this. 24hrs after your question,
    for tulip i gave "answer: 7/16x26tpi, a thread size [in US] you would need to special order."
    ----------------

    i should have suggested sooner, posting pics is most effective approach when requesting assistance, certainly in this case.
    re tulip thread: ROBBO55 "26 TPI Calculates to 0.98 pitch, A M11 x 1.0 is a sloppy fit"
    clearly having a close review on your behalf.
    vs
    your result in-hand: I bought a tap 11/1, cut the thread ... Alas, it doesn’t fit, it doesn’t screw on ...

    To clarify your are saying your newly cut M11/1 female thread did not screw onto an 8R burner? :-k

    2 different results.
    ROBBO55 tested thread, with a tap, the opposite way (tap into tulip), sloppy fit result, for me, it does not seem the difference is strictly his approach. (due to sloppy. if it were tight fit a tap may go where bolt will not. he reports M11/1 is sloppy fit. his result inline w/my expectation, as I tried M12 into 8R tulip. the bolt was just a tad too big).

    We have to wonder what is amiss?

    ONE thought: You are familiar with PT1 (8R copy) we have established.
    FYI there are as many as 6 other 8R copies all or most are Asian, those can be seen in this thread:
    8Rs and 8R-like stoves we have not seen any pics, are you sure it is 8R burner if that is what you have? i guess i do not know what you have in-hand.

    I presume it is clear we do want to help you.
    ---------------------
    Your objective is to sell parts... "... be able to offer silent burners for 8R, 98, 123R. And separately on Fri 1. [PT1?] Respectfully..."

    cc: @ROBBO55
     
    Last edited: 31 december 2022
  8. JP2

    JP2 Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    26 juni 2018
    Inlägg:
    1.528
    Från:
    Canada
    @mirumir
    Can we see your silence burner, maybe something else can be done.
     
  9. snwcmpr

    snwcmpr SotM Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    16 november 2011
    Inlägg:
    22.075
    Från:
    North Carolina
    You have the male thread.
    Look up the "Three Wire" method of thread pitch measurement.
    Measure the number of threads per inch.
     
  10. mirumir Ukraine

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    11 december 2022
    Inlägg:
    26
    Från:
    Ukraine
    Hello . Thanks for the help, anyway. I am very pleased that people responded and want to help. I understand that the 8R comes in several varieties and the threads may vary. I tried on the original 8R (with an iron key) I will try to order 7/16 26 inch taps - this will be the best option. Thread 11/1, cut on a lathe on a washer 5 mm thick. Once again, thank you all for your help and Happy New Year! Peace, Health and Success!!!
     
  11. mirumir Ukraine

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    11 december 2022
    Inlägg:
    26
    Från:
    Ukraine
  12. mirumir Ukraine

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    11 december 2022
    Inlägg:
    26
    Från:
    Ukraine
    a photo of a silent bell, I'll post it later. We have air raid alert.
     
  13. Ed Winskill

    Ed Winskill United States Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    20 augusti 2004
    Inlägg:
    15.006
    Från:
    Tacoma, Washinghton, USA
    Prayers hence. Heavenly King, Comforter, Spirit of Truth, who are everywhere present and fill all things, have mercy on us and save us.
    Gospodi pomiliui.

    Good luck.
     
    Last edited: 1 januari 2023
  14. mirumir Ukraine

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    11 december 2022
    Inlägg:
    26
    Från:
    Ukraine
    With prayers , Himers goes very well ! Glory to Ukraine and USA !
     
  15. Paul Lydon

    Paul Lydon United Kingdom Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    13 maj 2021
    Inlägg:
    213
    Från:
    Derbyshire, UK
    I hope for a happier 2023 in Ukraine and around the world.
     
  16. mirumir Ukraine

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    11 december 2022
    Inlägg:
    26
    Från:
    Ukraine
    Greetings to all ! I did not find a tap with a 7/16x26 thread in the catalogs. there are 7/16x20 and there are 7/16x28. Unfortunately, 7/16x28 is very rare, and it is extremely difficult to buy it. I ordered 7/16x20. I will try . Respectfully to all
     
  17. kerophile

    kerophile United Kingdom SotM Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    23 september 2004
    Inlägg:
    14.341
    Från:
    Far North of Scotland
  18. Tony Press

    Tony Press Netherlands Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    8 juni 2013
    Inlägg:
    10.858
    Från:
    Stinkpot Bay, Howden, Tasmania, Australia
    @mirumir

    I bought my 7/16 26tpi tap and thread from England. It was a specialist business.

    I will look for the information to send to you.


    Keep safe & best regards,

    Tony
     
  19. ROBBO55

    ROBBO55 Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    27 oktober 2014
    Inlägg:
    2.701
    Från:
    Somersby, New South Wales, Australia
    @mirumir

    OK, I went back to look at the stove again.
    I have a 7/16” x 26tpi BSB (British Standard Brass) tap. It screws comfortably into the burner bell. Good so far.

    I then tapped a piece of 3mm brass with the 7/16” x 26tpi BSB tap. It screwed onto the burner spigot 2/3 turn then locked. I couldn’t get it to go any further.
    Suspecting the tap was the problem I contacted @Tony Press and asked him to repeat the procedure. He came back with the same result.
    I tried a die on the spigot thread but stopped when it started to remove brass.

    SO
    One possibility
    BSB has a 55 deg profile and the Optimus thread is 60 deg. If so, a 7/16” x 26tpi BSC (British Standard Cycle) tap could work? But I don’t have one to try.
    @Colin Geer or anyone else have a 7/16” x 26tpi at 60 deg profile to try?

    The other possibility
    The thread isn’t 7/16” and this has just been a convenient size for cleaning existing threads. 7/16” converts to 11.11mm. I measured 11.33mm dia on the thread of two Optimus 8R stoves. I would normally expect to measure slightly smaller than the nominal size rather than slightly larger. From previous discussions we know many of the Swedish threads are not standard and this could be one. At a guess nominal 11.5mm x 26 TPI or M11.5 x 1.0?
    Happy to be proven wrong.
     
  20. Tony Press

    Tony Press Netherlands Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    8 juni 2013
    Inlägg:
    10.858
    Från:
    Stinkpot Bay, Howden, Tasmania, Australia
    I can confirm that the British Standard Brass BSB 7/16 26tpi tap will not produce the correct thread on new brass for the Svea 123 or Optimus 8R.

    It is ok for repairing damaged threads on a burner bell:
    18533A79-3AF6-46A7-B7DF-17BE1F3078B4.jpeg

    But a new female thread will not fit the vapouriser thread:

    Tapped with BSB 7/16 26tpi tap.
    21D2B8C5-D329-47FD-87A7-08CC7B8E9094.jpeg

    Will not fit this.
    99CE420B-A068-42E1-B100-636C423BF899.jpeg


    Best regards

    Tony