Sigg Tourist and MSR ‘Lowdown’ combination

Diskussion i 'Stove Forum' startad av presscall, 15 juni 2023.

  1. presscall

    presscall United Kingdom PotY Winner SotM Winner SotY Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    25 augusti 2009
    Inlägg:
    13.962
    Från:
    Lancashire, United Kingdom
    4C6665EA-E5C4-4117-B1E0-6229A3D8577F.jpeg


    The MSR ‘Lowdown’ or ‘Remote Stove Adapter’ as MSR also call it is intended to convert a canister-top stove (MSR’s Pocket Rocket Deluxe here) to a remote-canister stove. The stove valve is opened fully and the valve on the flexi-hose canister connector is used to control the flame, which given the fuel, it does as sensitively as the stove valve does. In the case of stoves such as the Deluxe and the Soto Windmaster equipped with a regulator to maintain output in cold conditions the device doesn’t compromise its action.

    3857A29B-1886-48B9-A7B0-6BB4E107B6C1.jpeg


    I specifically bought the ‘Lowdown’ believing it would enable me to use either of those top-performing gassies in my newly-acquired Sigg Tourist set. With a minor tweak to the ‘Lowdown’ it does indeed.

    Here’s the combination.

    2F2A6401-52D6-4C1D-80B9-84CAC4C69B12.jpeg

    E68F6BDD-169B-42DC-94DF-6258648E95E1.jpeg


    Soto Windmaster and MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe install equally well …

    737D741B-CEC2-425E-BC21-4393D6327F61.jpeg


    … though the MSR stove’s ignition ‘sparker’ is activated through a ventilation opening in the Sigg base, whereas the Soto’s isn’t so easily.

    9E3CCE06-5BD4-4637-9CB2-2022CA8C1DC7.jpeg


    I mentioned a modification has to be made to the ‘Lowdown’ to install it in the Sigg.

    Here’s the problem …

    4DD40543-81AA-4F82-BDEB-70EB2654F6E3.jpeg


    … and the solution is a saw-cut in the same position in each tripod leg.

    9787077A-9C58-4227-B61C-C71B6D02D4A9.jpeg


    The Sigg takes the weight of pots, should there be concerns that the saw-cuts weaken the legs, though with a thickness of the Sigg’s aluminium filling the saw-cuts, it becomes a technicality.

    That said, with the device in its orthodox role, it would take a very heavy pot to bend, much less shear, the stainless steel struts taking a third of the weight.

    1BCA8F7B-F087-4D64-837B-441C3F8A863E.jpeg


    The slots provide positive locking of the assembly, consistent with an inherent feature of the Sigg Tourist with its interlocking pots.

    FE8FDF5C-A3D9-419D-A2A7-72E3279310E5.jpeg


    The MSR stove’s built-in pot rests (detachable on the Soto) are stowed when it’s installed in the Sigg base and, valve opened beforehand, the valve control is flipped out of the way also.

    2F900E52-509D-4EDE-AE00-F8AEC4C84388.jpeg


    A very effective combination, not usurping the Svea 123 at all, but providing an alternative. Sigg themselves made an adaptor for the Tourist to mount on a Camping Gas S200 I believe, so it’s a modern refinement of an older concept but now utilising inherently much stronger performers than the venerable S200, and powered by less cold-sensitive modern lpg mixtures.

    A189D3B9-EE0D-4777-AFF8-BEF64D9E64A1.jpeg


    Controllability to outperform the Svea 123 on simmering ability is very much a strong point.



    John
     
    Last edited: 15 juni 2023
  2. Ed Winskill

    Ed Winskill United States Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    20 augusti 2004
    Inlägg:
    15.028
    Från:
    Tacoma, Washinghton, USA
    Most ingenious and, indeed, excellent.
     
  3. The Warrior

    The Warrior United States Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    5 december 2019
    Inlägg:
    3.053
    Från:
    Illinois, USA
    Very nice! The cut in the legs makes it appear that it's going through it, haha.
     
  4. presscall

    presscall United Kingdom PotY Winner SotM Winner SotY Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    25 augusti 2009
    Inlägg:
    13.962
    Från:
    Lancashire, United Kingdom
    The kit stows nicely.

    4CEBAB2B-A2D5-4803-829C-75459898CC25.jpeg
     
  5. William Ritchie

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    3 augusti 2015
    Inlägg:
    300
    Från:
    San Diego California USA
    Very nice conversion , thinking " within " rather than outside the box . Any plans for bending a new secondary accessible control valve . Cool stuff
     
    Last edited: 15 juni 2023
  6. presscall

    presscall United Kingdom PotY Winner SotM Winner SotY Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    25 augusti 2009
    Inlägg:
    13.962
    Från:
    Lancashire, United Kingdom
    No, I don’t see there’s a need to because the stove is perfectly and conveniently controlled with the valve at the canister.
     
  7. Dean

    Dean United Kingdom Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    11 augusti 2018
    Inlägg:
    716
    Från:
    Northants, England
    Earth to John: The CG C206 carts that I have (not particularly recent stock) are filled with a butane/propane mix, as are the pretenders like Go System 2190 and other more obscure makes including my most recent acquisition, a WELDING WALKOVER appliance cart Art.1120 (Italian?) which rather oddly tells you not to puncture or pierce it! - I guess that is why it is still full.
     
  8. presscall

    presscall United Kingdom PotY Winner SotM Winner SotY Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    25 augusti 2009
    Inlägg:
    13.962
    Från:
    Lancashire, United Kingdom
    @Dean
    I guess I had in mind the fuel contemporary to when the Sigg’s Campingaz adaptor was offered, a good few years ago now. I’ve tried out a modern Campingaz pierceable mixed-gas cartridge, peculiarly equipped with their ‘Gas Lock’ valve which prevents the escape of gas if the cart is detached from the appliance.

    So a pierceable gas canister that has a warning on it not to pierce it. Yes, sounds like someone has followed the instructions to the letter.
     
  9. Steviebear

    Steviebear Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    28 januari 2018
    Inlägg:
    65
    Från:
    Madison, Wisconsin USA
    Brilliant!
     
  10. Big Si

    Big Si Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    3 februari 2008
    Inlägg:
    1.124
    @presscall
    Nice on John, I've not brought a remote adaptor yet, it is on my birthday list, however. The Boys have brought me a massive Stanley flask for Father's Day to add to my flask collection, another strange hobby my wife tells me is not normal. Love anything MSR me.

    Si
     
  11. presscall

    presscall United Kingdom PotY Winner SotM Winner SotY Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    25 augusti 2009
    Inlägg:
    13.962
    Från:
    Lancashire, United Kingdom
    I gathered that, Si.

    884761F7-4CC4-4313-A175-20560D22B714.jpeg

    (Part of Si’s MSR collection at Newark)

    The ‘Lowdown’ (made in Korea it says on the box) is a precision job I can confirm, probably worth the extra compared with cheaper alternatives from unbranded sources. Certainly I had no hesitation in taking a Dremel cut-off wheel to it! Meaning, I knew it had plenty of reserve strength in those tripod struts to cope with the ‘tweak’.

    John
     
  12. Sizzler670 United Kingdom

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    23 maj 2026
    Inlägg:
    20
    Från:
    Clapham
    Good day gentlemen,
    I recently (last year)purchased an MSR lowdown adapter for use with a Windmaster, but on inspection I am a little disappointed with the finish on the threaded section which screws into the bottom of the stove. In particular the shoulder at the top of the (cast aluminium?)thread which would form a “mating” seal with the stove O ring, is or at least appears to be quite rough/unfinished. I’m wondering if, over a period of time this rough surface would cause damage to the sealing O ring at the top end of the thread inside the stove, or perhaps I’m just overthinking this issue. I’ve contacted MSR twice but haven’t received any response.
    Your opinions would be appreciated

    you may have to zoom in onto the pics to see what I mean. The rough cast surface of the lowdown adapter versus the smooth thread and top surface of the “disposable”gas cartridge.
    I can live with the slight loss of fine gas control from the (needle?) valve on the adapter versus the Soto, balanced against the big improvement in stability on what would otherwise be a fairly tall setup
     

    Bifogade filer:

  13. presscall

    presscall United Kingdom PotY Winner SotM Winner SotY Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    25 augusti 2009
    Inlägg:
    13.962
    Från:
    Lancashire, United Kingdom
    @Sizzler670
    Looking closely at mine …

    IMG_6166.jpeg

    IMG_6167.jpeg

    … I see why you’re concerned, since it’s hardly a mirror finish! That said, I can report that there’s been no adverse effect on the O-ring seal it’s been in contact with after some considerable use since I coupled up the stove and gadget.

    Regarding flame regulation, I know the Low Down’s instructions specify completely opening the stove’s valve and controlling the output with the canister-mounted valve, but I don’t see a problem if the reverse is applied - canister valve opened completely and stove valve controls the flame - or a combination of both with the stove valve doing the fine tuning. True, that does away with one of the stated benefits of the device (not to have to reach anywhere in the vicinity of the pot) but there’s plenty of room to control the valve on the stove and the plot is so much more stable now also.
     
    Last edited: 19 augusti 2026
  14. hikerduane

    hikerduane Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    1 mars 2010
    Inlägg:
    10.875
    Från:
    Plumas County, CA
    Mine looks a little better than John’s. Have not had a chance to use it yet.
    Duane
     
  15. Jon Vara

    Jon Vara United States Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    4 juni 2025
    Inlägg:
    71
    Från:
    Cabot, Vermont, USA
    Very nice! Might it have been better to cut slots in the base section of the Sigg pot support, rather than making saw cuts in the stove legs? Agreed that any weakening of the slotted legs is unlikely to cause problems.k But slotting Sigg support would not not have any effect at all on its strength or functionality, at least as far as I can see.

    That said, I can understand why you might be reluctant to take a cutting tool to a Sigg Tourist set in seemingly pristine condition.
     
  16. presscall

    presscall United Kingdom PotY Winner SotM Winner SotY Winner Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    25 augusti 2009
    Inlägg:
    13.962
    Från:
    Lancashire, United Kingdom
    Not that, but its value as having belonged to a friend, now deceased.
     
  17. Sizzler670 United Kingdom

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    23 maj 2026
    Inlägg:
    20
    Från:
    Clapham
    Thank you for your input @presscall. I may just take some 2000 grit wet and dry paper to the top end and try to get a slightly better finish. I’ll probably just block the hole temporarily with bluetack to keep any loose bits out of the gas port whilst I smooth out some of the rough spots which I can feel with my finger.
     
  18. Oldhenry1 United States

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    29 mars 2021
    Inlägg:
    170
    Från:
    Puget Sound, WA U.S.A.
    I missed the initial post, brilliant Sigg Tourist conversion @presscall !!

    The MSR lowdown I picked up a few years ago, the mating surface looks pristine on compared to the pictures of the ones shown here. I used a GAZ 270 burner with a Coleman valve conversion on it daily for quite awhile, it currently has a MSR Pocket Rocket II burner mounted to it. The PR-II seems to have a much finer burner control.
     
  19. Jon Vara

    Jon Vara United States Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    4 juni 2025
    Inlägg:
    71
    Från:
    Cabot, Vermont, USA
    That's a perfectly good reason for leaving the cookset in its original condition. I'm so taken by the idea that I will probably convert my Firefly in the same way--but given my lack of attachment to my rather battered old Sigg Tourist set, I will probably slot the cookset rather than the stove legs.!!

    This is a great idea, so thanks for sharing it!
     
  20. Jon Vara

    Jon Vara United States Subscriber

    Offline
    Blev medlem:
    4 juni 2025
    Inlägg:
    71
    Från:
    Cabot, Vermont, USA
    I should have typed "Pocket Rocket" in the post above--not sure how I happened to type "Firefly" instead. My brain usually functions moderately well, but it does go off the rails occasionally....